A senior woman manager chairing an Internal Committee meeting at an office table with three colleagues

POSH Presiding Officer: Who Qualifies, Can She Be Junior?

Quick answer: The Presiding Officer must be a woman employed at a senior level at the workplace (Section 4(2)(a) of the POSH Act, 2013). The Act does not say she must outrank the person accused, and the Allahabad High Court (2015) and Rajasthan High Court (2018) both rejected that argument. If no senior woman works at that office, the Act tells you where to look next.

What does the POSH Act say about the Presiding Officer?

The POSH Act is Act No. 14 of 2013, enacted on 22 April 2013 and in force from 9 December 2013. Section 4(1) requires every employer to constitute an Internal Committee by an order in writing.

Section 4(2)(a) says the committee shall have “a Presiding Officer who shall be a woman employed at a senior level at workplace from amongst the employees”. Three conditions follow from those words:

  • She must be a woman. A man cannot be the Presiding Officer.
  • She must be employed at a senior level.
  • She should ordinarily come from among your own employees at that workplace.

The employer also nominates at least two employee members and one external member, and at least one-half of all members must be women. For the full text, see our guide to Section 4 of the POSH Act.

What does “senior level” mean, and who decides?

The Act does not define “senior level”; Section 2, the definitions section, has no entry for it. The choice is yours as the employer. Treat it as a test of her standing in the organisation, not of her rank against any one employee: a head of department or senior manager will usually qualify, a trainee will not. Record in the constitution order why she is senior, such as her grade or managerial role, in case the committee is challenged.

Can the Presiding Officer be junior to the person accused?

The Act does not require her to be senior to the respondent. Two High Courts have said so in plain terms.

Allahabad High Court, 27 May 2015 (Writ-A No. 31659 of 2015). The complainant wanted the committee reconstituted because the senior woman officer newly placed on it, a DGM (Planning), was subordinate to the officer complained against. The Court refused. It held there is nothing in Section 4 “which requires the lady member to be senior in rank to the officer against whom the allegation of sexual harassment are brought”, and that the section “only requires the lady member to be of Senior Level”.

Rajasthan High Court, 6 April 2018 (S.B. Civil Writ No. 2313/2018). The respondent, an Additional Director, said the inquiry was invalid because the chairperson was a Deputy Director. The Court rejected this. It said “the Committee cannot be constituted as per the hierarchy of the officials against whom complaints are received” and that “the only requirement is that there has to be woman employed at a senior level”. If the argument were accepted, it added, the committee’s composition would always depend on the rank of the person complained against. The Court did set the inquiry aside, but on a different ground: breach of natural justice. On composition, it also noted the committee was a standing committee formed in 2014 for a three-year term, not one formed for this complaint.

Both cases involved government employers and are single-judge High Court rulings, so they are persuasive rather than binding everywhere. But their reasoning rests on the words of Section 4(2)(a), which apply to every employer. So a senior-level woman can, on the text of the Act, preside over a complaint against someone who ranks above her.

When does the respondent’s rank still matter?

Seniority is not the test, but independence is. A Presiding Officer whose appraisal the respondent signs may face pressure, and the inquiry may look unfair.

The Delhi High Court addressed this on 4 December 2020 (W.P.(C) 3396/2019). The complaint was against the former chairman of a council that comes under a Union government department. Among the principles it listed, the Court said that where persons “at the helm of affairs” are themselves the respondents, the committee “cannot be one of their choice or of persons who have worked under them”. On the facts, it directed the Cabinet Secretariat to constitute an independent committee within four weeks.

Read this carefully. The Court did not add a rank rule to Section 4. It did say that allegations against senior-level officers should be inquired into by an external, independent committee, “more so in the case of a Government establishment where an alternative mechanism can be easily evolved”. That was said on the facts of a government case, and it is not settled law that every private employer must bring in an outside committee when a senior person is accused.

The practical lesson for any employer: if your Presiding Officer reports to the respondent, or is a witness or close colleague in the matter, consider nominating another senior woman for that case under Section 4, and record why.

What if there is no senior woman at that office?

Section 4(2)(a) and its two provisos set out where to look, in order:

  1. A senior-level woman employee at the workplace itself.
  2. If none is available, a senior-level woman from your other offices or administrative units referred to in Section 4(1).
  3. If those offices also have no senior-level woman employee, a Presiding Officer nominated “from any other workplace of the same employer or other department or organisation”.

How long does she serve, and when must she be removed?

Under Section 4(3), the Presiding Officer and every member hold office for the period the employer specifies, not exceeding three years from the date of nomination. Put the start date and end date in the order, and diarise the renewal.

Section 4(5) says she shall be removed if she breaches confidentiality under Section 16, is convicted of an offence or faces a pending inquiry into one, is found guilty in or faces disciplinary proceedings, or has so abused her position that her continuing in office would be prejudicial to the public interest. Any vacancy is filled by fresh nomination under Section 4.

Duty or time limitWhat the Act saysSection
Constitute the Internal CommitteeBy an order in writing4(1)
Presiding OfficerA senior-level woman employee; if none, from other offices, then outside4(2)(a)
Gender balanceAt least one-half of members nominated must be womenProviso to 4(2)
TermNot more than 3 years from nomination4(3)
Display the constitution orderAt a conspicuous place in the workplace19(b)
ComplaintWithin 3 months of the incident or last incident, extendable by up to 3 months for recorded reasons9(1)
InquiryCompleted within 90 days11(4)
Inquiry reportWithin 10 days of completing the inquiry13(1)
Employer acts on the reportWithin 60 days13(4)
Not constituting a committeeFine up to ₹50,00026(1)

Frequently asked questions

Can a man be the Presiding Officer of an Internal Committee?

No. Section 4(2)(a) of the POSH Act says the Presiding Officer shall be a woman employed at a senior level. Men can sit on the committee as employee members or as the external member, as long as at least one-half of all members are women.

Must the Presiding Officer be senior to the person accused?

The Act does not say so. The Allahabad High Court in 2015 and the Rajasthan High Court in 2018 held that Section 4 only requires a woman at a senior level. Independence still matters, so avoid a Presiding Officer who reports directly to the respondent.

What does “senior level” mean under the POSH Act?

The Act does not define it. The employer decides, based on the woman’s standing in the organisation, such as her grade or managerial role. Record the reason in the constitution order so you can explain the choice if the committee is challenged.

Can the Presiding Officer come from another office or organisation?

Yes, in order. If no senior woman is available at that workplace, nominate one from your other offices or units. If none is available there either, Section 4(2)(a) allows nomination from another workplace of the same employer or another department or organisation.

When must a Presiding Officer be removed?

Section 4(5) requires removal if she breaches confidentiality under Section 16, faces a conviction or pending inquiry into an offence, is found guilty in or faces disciplinary proceedings, or has so abused her position that her continuing in office would be prejudicial to the public interest. The vacancy is filled by fresh nomination under Section 4.

Is your Internal Committee set up correctly?

If you are not sure your Presiding Officer meets Section 4, start with the free Internal Committee check: a few yes-or-no questions on Sections 4, 19, 21 and 22 that show the gaps at once. To see how Manas sets up and supports your committee, with Dr. Priya Dubey Sharma, Founder & Consulting Psychologist, as the External Member, visit our POSH compliance page. More employer questions are answered in the POSH FAQ.

Sources

Written by
Manas Editorial Team

Plain-language guides to POSH compliance for Indian employers, based on the Act, the Rules and court rulings. POSH compliance at Manas Center is led by Dr. Priya Dubey Sharma, Founder & Consulting Psychologist, as External Member.

POSH compliance →  ·  Free committee check →